1  Story Time

Coors Field, 9/18/2001

1.1 My First Game

It’s September 18, 2001, one week after 9/11 and also my ninth birthday. The country is stirring itself back into action with the hope that regular activities will provide a reprieve from the pain.

At 5:30 AM, I’m already up and ready to see my very first professional baseball game. Rising early is part eagerness and part necessity. To get to Coors Field, my family and I need to drive 550 miles from my hometown of Billings, Montana to Denver, Colorado. As we cross through Wyoming, little do I know that soon I will witness the most exciting in-person baseball game of my life.

The Colorado Rockies opponent, you ask? The soon-to-be World Series champion Arizona Diamondbacks. Before the game, I stand on the third base line and after three attempts because he is so tall and I so short finally get Randy Johnson to sign my program. The starting pitcher for the Diamondbacks that night is his counterpart in pitching dominance, Curt Schilling. Johnson would win the Cy Young Award that season with Schilling finishing second in voting. They would together pitch a postseason for the record books.

On the surface, below the surface, above the surface, the 62-81 Rockies seem a weak match for the Diamondbacks. Their chances look even bleaker when the Diamondbacks score six runs in the top of the first inning. But these are things my nine-year-old brain doesn’t even care to compute amid the sights of perfect green grass, the hypnotic motion of Todd Helton throwing warmup grounders to his fellow infielders, the sound of the public address announcer belting out what may well be a roll call for heaven.

As good as Schilling is, one does not simply walk into Coors Field and pitch well. This was especially the case before 2002 when the Rockies had their famous epiphany about limiting the offense-enhancing effects of Denver’s elevation and aridity by storing baseballs in a humidor. As if on some sort of Mountain Time cue, Jose Ortiz and Todd Helton hit back to back home runs in the third inning to cut the Diamondbacks lead in half. By the end of the fifth inning, the Rockies have narrowed their deficit to 6-5 and sent Schilling packing early. Entering the bottom of the ninth, the Rockies and Diamondbacks have scored a combined 17 runs with the Rockies trailing 9-8.

At this point, what more could my nine-year-old self have asked for? My family had driven me across three states to see a baseball game. I got Randy Johnson’s autograph. Todd Helton had homered. I ate some Dippin’ Dots.

My heart was filled to its brim, and then bang, Todd Helton drives a ball deep to center for his second home run of the game. A small crowd for Coors yet a huge crowd in my eyes erupts as the Rockies tie the game 9-9. For a kid from Montana, I was as wide-eyed as eyes widen.

The next batter, Jeff Cirillo, decides to join Helton in making my first game one for the ages. He too hits a home run, the second set of back-to-back home runs of the night for the Rockies—this time off Byun Hyung Kim, a foreshadowing of World Series meltdowns to come.

Having trailed the entire game until the final inning, the Rockies win 10-9 in exhilarating style.

My Dad and I at the game…

1.2 Back-to-Back Home Run Endings

My Dad told me that I’d probably never see another game in-person that ends in back-to-back home runs for the rest of my life. And he’s probably right. From 1990 to 2020 (the years of focus for this project), only 27 games ended in back-to-back home runs. The chances of seeing one of those games was 1 in 2,632, a little less than one per season.

Were any of you at one of these games? Technically, there were 28 games, but one set of those home runs happened in the 7th inning with the game being called immediately after due to a rain delay.

Table 1.1: Games Ending in Back-to-Back Home Runs - 1990 to 2020
Row ID Game ID Date Home Team Away Team Inning Batter Pitcher Event
1341313 CIN199605070 1996-05-07 CIN LAN 12 Eric Anthony Todd Worrell HR/L9LD
1341314 CIN199605070 1996-05-07 CIN LAN 12 Eric Davis Todd Worrell HR/L89XD
1537146 CLE199607180 1996-07-18 CLE MIN 9 Manny Ramirez Dave Stevens HR/F8LXD.B-H
1537147 CLE199607180 1996-07-18 CLE MIN 9 Eddie Murray Eddie Guardado HR/F7D.B-H
2087098 FLO199609210 1996-09-21 FLO HOU 9 Jeff Conine Billy Wagner HR/F9D
2087099 FLO199609210 1996-09-21 FLO HOU 9 Devon White Billy Wagner HR/F78XD
4108989 PIT199708252 1997-08-25 PIT LAN 9 Joe Randa Todd Worrell HR/F8RXD.1-H
4108990 PIT199708252 1997-08-25 PIT LAN 9 Mark Smith Todd Worrell HR/F7D
737961 BOS199906140 1999-06-14 BOS MIN 9 Darren Lewis Mike Trombley HR/F7D
737962 BOS199906140 1999-06-14 BOS MIN 9 Jeff Frye Mike Trombley HR/L78D
1560276 CLE200004160 2000-04-16 CLE TEX 9 Manny Ramirez John Wetteland HR/8
1560277 CLE200004160 2000-04-16 CLE TEX 9 Jim Thome John Wetteland HR/9
21565 ANA200005140 2000-05-14 ANA TEX 9 Troy Glaus Francisco Cordero HR/9
21566 ANA200005140 2000-05-14 ANA TEX 9 Scott Spiezio Francisco Cordero HR/9
3358446 NYA200008080 2000-08-08 NYA OAK 9 Bernie Williams Jason Isringhausen HR/9
3358447 NYA200008080 2000-08-08 NYA OAK 9 David Justice Jason Isringhausen HR/8
1748628 COL200109180 2001-09-18 COL ARI 9 Todd Helton Byung-Hyun Kim HR/8
1748629 COL200109180 2001-09-18 COL ARI 9 Jeff Cirillo Byung-Hyun Kim HR/8
373384 ATL200208190 2002-08-19 ATL COL 9 Gary Sheffield Jose Jimenez HR/78
373385 ATL200208190 2002-08-19 ATL COL 9 Chipper Jones Jose Jimenez HR/9
1199309 CHN200404160 2004-04-16 CHN CIN 9 Sammy Sosa Danny Graves HR/9/F
1199310 CHN200404160 2004-04-16 CHN CIN 9 Moises Alou Danny Graves HR/7/F
382757 ATL200406010 2004-06-01 ATL MON 9 Nick Green Rocky Biddle HR/7/F.2-H(UR);1-H(UR);B-H(UR)
382758 ATL200406010 2004-06-01 ATL MON 9 J.D. Drew Rocky Biddle HR/9/F.B-H(UR)
1398725 CIN200504040 2005-04-04 CIN NYN 9 Adam Dunn Braden Looper HR/89/F+.1-H
1398726 CIN200504040 2005-04-04 CIN NYN 9 Joe Randa Braden Looper HR/7/F
2169799 FLO200908020 2009-08-02 FLO CHN 9 Dan Uggla Kevin Gregg HR/7/F
2169800 FLO200908020 2009-08-02 FLO CHN 9 Cody Ross Kevin Gregg HR/7/F
2523869 KCA201209150 2012-09-15 KCA ANA 9 Billy Butler Ernesto Frieri HR/8/F.1-H
2523870 KCA201209150 2012-09-15 KCA ANA 9 Salvador Perez Ernesto Frieri HR/7/F
1451760 CIN201305070 2013-05-07 CIN ATL 9 Devin Mesoraco Craig Kimbrel HR/89/L
1451761 CIN201305070 2013-05-07 CIN ATL 9 Shin-Soo Choo Craig Kimbrel HR/78/F
4015412 PHI201305190 2013-05-19 PHI CIN 9 Erik Kratz Aroldis Chapman HR/7/F
4015413 PHI201305190 2013-05-19 PHI CIN 9 Freddy Galvis Aroldis Chapman HR/7/L
836274 BOS201406180 2014-06-18 BOS MIN 10 David Ortiz Casey Fien HR/9/L
836275 BOS201406180 2014-06-18 BOS MIN 10 Mike Napoli Casey Fien HR/8/F
1667689 CLE201608190 2016-08-19 CLE TOR 9 Jose Ramirez Roberto Osuna HR/9/F
1667690 CLE201608190 2016-08-19 CLE TOR 9 Tyler Naquin Roberto Osuna HR8/F/IPHR
2354575 HOU201608260 2016-08-26 HOU TBA 9 Carlos Correa Alex Colome HR/9/F
2354576 HOU201608260 2016-08-26 HOU TBA 9 Evan Gattis Alex Colome HR/7/F
5534838 TOR201707260 2017-07-26 TOR OAK 9 Justin Smoak Santiago Casilla HR/89/F.1-H
5534839 TOR201707260 2017-07-26 TOR OAK 9 Kendrys Morales Santiago Casilla HR/89/F
2991567 MIL201804030 2018-04-03 MIL SLN 9 Christian Yelich Dominic Leone HR/8/F
2991568 MIL201804030 2018-04-03 MIL SLN 9 Ryan Braun Dominic Leone HR/78/F
1292959 CHN201807260 2018-07-26 CHN ARI 9 David Bote Brad Boxberger HR/8/F.1-H
1292960 CHN201807260 2018-07-26 CHN ARI 9 Anthony Rizzo Brad Boxberger HR/89/F
2561155 KCA201808240 2018-08-24 KCA CLE 9 Ryan O’Hearn Cody Allen HR/7/F
2561156 KCA201808240 2018-08-24 KCA CLE 9 Hunter Dozier Cody Allen HR/89/F
3666068 NYN201809131 2018-09-13 NYN MIA 9 Michael Conforto Kyle Barraclough HR/9/F
3666069 NYN201809131 2018-09-13 NYN MIA 9 Todd Frazier Kyle Barraclough HR/78/F
5543238 TOR201809200 2018-09-20 TOR TBA 9 Lourdes Gurriel Sergio Romo HR/7/F.1-H
5543239 TOR201809200 2018-09-20 TOR TBA 9 Justin Smoak Sergio Romo HR/9/F
3476385 NYA201904120 2019-04-12 NYA CHA 7 Eloy Jimenez Chad Green HR/8/F
3476386 NYA201904120 2019-04-12 NYA CHA 7 James McCann Chad Green HR/9/L
3481355 NYA201909010 2019-09-01 NYA OAK 9 Brett Gardner Liam Hendriks HR/89/F
3481356 NYA201909010 2019-09-01 NYA OAK 9 Mike Ford Liam Hendriks HR/8/F

1.3 Hall of Famer

Much to my delight, Todd Helton was elected to the baseball Hall of Fame this January, forever to be enshrined as one of the greatest players to ever play the game.

In an interview capturing his post-election emotions, he said, “‘playing’ 162 games, there’s sometimes where you’re just not feeling it…and you go out and you play at Coors Field…and the fans get you energized…and they get you ready to play. And you never know when the one kid is there that that’s his first time watching you play. So that’s what I thought about when I when out there…”

Being now in my thirties, I’ve grown a bit too old to look up to athletes or imagine that a comment like this can fully explain human motivations. Yet I cannot deny that I was that kid that night—September 18, 2001—and express my gratitude to the Toddfather for memories that will last a lifetime.

1.4 The State of the Rockies

As satisfying as it was to look back on fond childhood and Rockies memories, the Rockies franchise is currently in shambles. They lost a franchise-worst 103 games last year despite having a $171 million dollar payroll. This year a successful season will likely be measured on the basis of not losing 100 games again. They opened this season by losing their first game 16-1 and allowing 13 runs in a single inning, an embarrassing outing and what feels emblematic of whatever dull torture remains of this season.

Last year’s World Series proved that losing 100 games does not prevent teams from fairly imminent success. Both the 2023 WS-winning Texas Rangers and WS-losing Arizona Diamondbacks lost 100 games just two years before. But the chances the Rockies could replicate this reversal in even five years seems a far-fetched notion. Organizational incompetence is the primary issue, and the condition of their roster the primary symptom.

The lone players on their major league roster that appear to have a legitimate shot at playing leading roles in any future competitive window are 25-year old Nolan Jones and 22-year old Ezequiel Tovar, both now in their sophomore seasons, though a case could be made for Brenton Doyle after a hot start to 2024. Jones was worth almost four wins himself last season compared to a typical replacement-level player as measured by Wins Above Replacement (WAR). Tovar finished 2023 as a Gold Glove finalist for his defensive prowess, putting up 1.6 WAR despite having a relatively weak offensive season. The Rockies demonstrated their faith in his talent by signing him to a $63 millon dollar contract through 2030.

Ezequiel Tovar and Nolan Jones, Credit: AP Photo, Jeff Roberson

Given the woeful state of their roster, it is no surprise that I and fellow Rockies fans are intensely interested in the development of Jones and Tovar. If Jones regresses—some suspect his success last season was unsustainable due to an extremely high batting average on balls in play, and his 2024 is already off to a horrific start—and Tovar doesn’t progress offensively, the Rockies will be in an even worse predicament than they already are. If they both build on their rookie performances and top prospects like Adael Amador emerge as contributors, the Rockies future will look less apocalyptic—perhaps normal enough for the eyes of the next generation of nine-year-old fans to widen.